What Richmond Can Learn from Detroit's Redevelopment of Greektown

Revitalization Isn't About Demolition. It's About Vision.

For decades, cities across America have wrestled with the same question: How do you bring life back to a struggling downtown?

Some cities responded by tearing down aging buildings and hoping new construction would solve their problems. Others looked at what they already had, invested in existing neighborhoods, partnered with private businesses, and created destinations that residents and tourists wanted to visit.

Detroit's Greektown is one of the country's best examples of the latter approach.

Today, Greektown is a thriving entertainment district filled with restaurants, hotels, nightlife, sporting events, residential development, and tourism. While Detroit still faces significant challenges, Greektown demonstrates what can happen when a city commits to building upon its existing assets instead of constantly replacing them.

Richmond should take notice.

As Richmond debates the future of downtown, including the demolition of the Richmond Coliseum and the construction of yet another hotel, Detroit offers valuable lessons about economic development, historic preservation, public-private partnerships, and creating authentic destinations.

A Neighborhood Worth Investing In

Greektown has existed for generations.

Rather than treating the district as obsolete, Detroit recognized that its history was one of its greatest competitive advantages.

City leaders and private investors focused on:

• preserving historic buildings;

• encouraging restaurant and entertainment investment;

• improving streetscapes;

• enhancing pedestrian safety;

• expanding residential opportunities;

• attracting hotel development where demand existed; and

• connecting Greektown with nearby attractions such as professional sports venues, the riverfront, and downtown offices.

The result was not one isolated project.

It became an ecosystem.

Restaurants supported hotels.

Hotels supported sporting events.

Sporting events supported nightlife.

Nightlife supported additional investment.

Each success created momentum for the next.

Richmond Continues to Think Project by Project

Richmond often approaches redevelopment differently.

Instead of asking how existing assets can work together, major projects are frequently evaluated independently.

The Diamond District.

The Coliseum site.

Downtown hotels.

Broad Street.

Shockoe Bottom.

The riverfront.

Each receives separate attention, yet residents rarely hear a comprehensive strategy explaining how all of these investments will reinforce one another.

Detroit demonstrates that successful downtown redevelopment is rarely the product of one building.

It comes from connecting destinations into an experience.

Historic Buildings Create Character

One of Greektown's greatest strengths is authenticity.

Visitors cannot replicate its atmosphere in suburban shopping centers.

Historic architecture gives the district identity.

People come because it feels unique.

Richmond possesses similar opportunities.

Historic Main Street Station.

Shockoe Slip.

Shockoe Bottom.

Jackson Ward.

Broad Street's historic commercial buildings.

The Richmond Coliseum itself represents another piece of Richmond's civic history, regardless of one's opinion about its future.

Historic preservation and economic development are not mutually exclusive.

Detroit has shown they often complement each other.

Public-Private Partnerships Matter

Greektown's resurgence did not occur through government alone.

Private developers, business owners, financial institutions, and local government all played important roles.

Government established conditions for investment.

Private businesses supplied capital.

Restaurants expanded.

Hotels opened.

Entertainment venues flourished.

Successful cities recognize that government should often facilitate development rather than attempt to direct every aspect of it.

Richmond should continue seeking partnerships that leverage private investment while protecting taxpayers from unnecessary financial risk.

Entertainment Drives Economic Activity

Greektown succeeds because people have reasons to visit.

Professional sports.

Casinos.

Restaurants.

Nightlife.

Festivals.

Live music.

Walkable streets.

Visitors often spend entire evenings downtown.

That spending supports thousands of jobs and generates tax revenue.

Richmond already has important anchors.

The Altria Theater.

Brown's Island.

The Convention Center.

Virginia Commonwealth University.

The CarMax ballpark.

The Canal Walk.

The James River.

The question is whether these destinations are being intentionally connected into one cohesive visitor experience.

The Coliseum Question

No comparison between Richmond and Detroit is complete without discussing the Richmond Coliseum.

Detroit has repeatedly demonstrated a willingness to renovate, repurpose, or reinvest in major assets when economically feasible.

Michigan Central Station, once considered beyond saving, now stands as an internationally recognized example of adaptive reuse following Ford Motor Company's investment.

Greektown similarly benefited from preserving its identity while modernizing its infrastructure.

Richmond faces a different decision regarding the Coliseum.

Supporters of demolition argue that redevelopment of the site presents greater long-term opportunities.

Others believe the City never fully demonstrated that renovation, adaptive reuse, or public-private redevelopment options were exhausted before demolition became the preferred strategy.

Whatever one's position, the public benefits when decisions are supported by transparent analyses comparing alternatives, projected costs, anticipated revenues, financing structures, and long-term economic impacts.

Walkability Is Economic Development

Greektown encourages visitors to walk.

That sounds simple.

It is actually one of the district's greatest economic strengths.

People walking between restaurants, hotels, sporting events, and entertainment venues spend money.

Businesses benefit.

Public safety improves through activity.

Property values increase.

Richmond has made progress with streetscape improvements, bike infrastructure, and riverfront connectivity, but opportunities remain to better connect downtown destinations into a seamless pedestrian experience.

Transparency Builds Confidence

Detroit's redevelopment efforts have not been free from criticism.

Large redevelopment projects invariably generate debate over public incentives, private investment, and neighborhood impacts.

One lesson for Richmond is the value of maintaining public confidence through open communication. For significant projects, residents benefit from timely access to supporting studies, financial assumptions, alternative proposals considered, and the rationale for major decisions. When that information is readily available, disagreements can focus on the merits rather than on whether the public has enough information to evaluate the decision.

Economic Development Is More Than Construction

Cities sometimes measure success by cranes.

But cranes eventually disappear.

The real measure is whether people continue coming downtown years later.

Greektown succeeds because businesses remain open.

People live there.

Tourists visit.

Employers invest nearby.

Restaurants continue opening.

The district has become part of Detroit's identity.

Richmond should evaluate redevelopment proposals using similar long-term metrics:

• Permanent jobs created.

• Private investment leveraged.

• Tourism growth.

• Hotel occupancy.

• Restaurant revenues.

• Convention activity.

• Property tax growth.

• Sales tax generation.

• Residential population increases.

• Small business formation.

These indicators provide a fuller picture than ribbon-cuttings alone.

The Bottom Line

Detroit's Greektown offers Richmond an important reminder: successful downtowns are built through sustained investment, preservation where appropriate, partnerships, and a connected vision rather than a series of isolated projects.

Richmond has many of the ingredients needed for a vibrant urban core: historic neighborhoods, cultural institutions, higher education, riverfront amenities, and a growing population. The challenge is weaving those assets into a coordinated strategy that encourages residents and visitors to spend more time downtown.

The discussion about the Coliseum, hotels, entertainment, and future development should therefore be part of a broader conversation about what kind of downtown Richmond wants to create over the next generation. Looking at examples like Greektown can help inform that conversation, while recognizing that Richmond's circumstances, finances, and community priorities differ from Detroit's.

The lesson from Detroit is not to copy another city wholesale.

It is to recognize that redevelopment succeeds when it creates places people want to experience, preserves what makes a city distinctive, and builds confidence through thoughtful planning and public engagement.

Brian K. Telfair
Publisher & Editor | The Richmond Chronicle

Independent commentary and investigative analysis on Richmond government, public spending, economic development, and the decisions shaping the city’s future.

The Richmond Chronicle
Asking the questions City Hall would rather not answer.